
By Conrad Youngblood
In 1886 Richard von Krafft-Ebing, a professor of psychiatry teaching in Graz, Austria, published a book about the sexual life and everything he thought could go wrong with it. He called it Psychopathia Sexualis. He wrote it for doctors and lawyers. When he reached the parts he thought too revolting for German, he wrote them in Latin. A doctor would have studied Latin. Most people hadn’t.
It didn’t stay with the doctors. The book went through twelve editions before he died in 1902, and people who saw themselves in its pages wrote him letters. Some of those letters became case histories. Some argued with him.
He also gave us the words. Sadism came from the Marquis de Sade. Masochism came from Leopold von Sacher-Masoch, an Austrian novelist who was still alive in 1890 when his name became a diagnosis. Twenty years earlier, Sacher-Masoch had published Venus in Furs, the story of a man who talks a woman into owning him. A novelist wrote desire. A doctor filed it under disease.
That filing lasted more than a century. I wrote a book, Lost in the Sauce: Pain, Psychosis & Pleasure, tracing how it came undone.
Lived experience
The people living it wrote limits down before psychiatry ever did. On December 8, 1869, Sacher-Masoch signed a contract with Fanny Pistor. On his word of honor, he would be her slave for six months and carry out her wishes. It also had limits. She couldn’t demand anything that would dishonor him as a man or as a citizen. She had to leave him six hours a day for his own work, and she could never look at his letters. When the six months were up, they would go back to the loving relationship they’d had before.
He gave her six months of his will. He kept his honor, six hours a day, and his mail.
That is a negotiated scene, in ink, two decades before his name became a diagnosis.
In a footnote, Krafft-Ebing described rough men who whipped their wives, and wives who suffered it for love without any desire for the blows. He called it a pseudo form, something that could pass for masochism but wasn’t. What separated the two, for him, was whether she wanted the blows.
Whether the other person wanted it. Psychiatry would take more than a hundred years to make that the rule.
DSM
In 1952 the American Psychiatric Association published its first diagnostic manual. It filed sexual deviation under sociopathic personality and named sexual sadism among the examples, beside
homosexuality, transvestism, and fetishism. Under sexual sadism it also put rape, sexual assault, and mutilation. An article in the American Medical Association’s ethics journal later pointed out that this lumped the harmless together with the terrible.
In 1968 the second edition gave sadism and masochism codes of their own. In 1973 the APA voted homosexuality out of the manual. Sadism and masochism stayed.
In 1983 the people doing it wrote their own line down. A New York group called Gay Male S/M Activists put out a statement of purpose, and it was the first place three words appeared together: safe, sane, and consensual. Thirty years later, David Stein, one of the group’s founders, wrote that consent alone isn’t enough. Safe, he said, points to how the scene turns out and to the ongoing quality of the relationship.
Then the research caught up. In 2008, a national survey of nearly 20,000 Australians found the people who did BDSM no more likely than anyone else to have been coerced into sex, and no more likely to be unhappy or anxious. The authors concluded that for most participants, BDSM is a sexual interest, not a symptom of past abuse.
Depathologization
The countries moved first. In 1995 Denmark took sadomasochism off its national list of diagnoses, the first country to do it. Sweden removed its fetish and sadomasochism diagnoses in 2009, and the head of its national health board said these behaviors were neither illnesses nor perversions. Norway followed in 2010, Finland in 2011, and Iceland in 2015. Much of that push came from a Norwegian campaign called Revise F65. Here at home, NCSF’s DSM revisions work pressed the same case on the American manual.
In 2013 the fifth edition of the DSM split the idea in two. It separated a paraphilia, an unusual sexual interest, from a paraphilic disorder. An interest alone is no longer a diagnosis. To become a disorder, it has to cause the person distress or impairment, or involve someone who didn’t consent. Ray Blanchard, who chaired the group that rewrote that chapter, called the old criteria a logical absurdity. A person, he said, can practice sexual masochism without having a mental disorder.
In 2019 the World Health Organization adopted the eleventh edition of its International Classification of Diseases, in force since 2022. It removed sadomasochism, along with fetishism. The working group called these private behavior: no real impact on public health, and no treatment called for or wanted. What it kept was coercive sexual sadism disorder, arousal from making a non-consenting person suffer. That definition specifically excludes consensual sadism and masochism.
It drew one more line, and it’s the one I’d hand to anybody still carrying shame about what they want. For a disorder involving only consenting partners, the distress can’t come from other people rejecting the desire, or from fear that they will.
Shame that comes from other people’s disapproval doesn’t count.
Krafft-Ebing put the darkest parts in Latin so most people couldn’t read them. The people in those pages read them anyway and wrote back. Sacher-Masoch’s contract, the 1983 statement, the Revise F65 campaign, and the work NCSF does now all belong to that same long reply.
Consent was the line all along.
My book translates the Latin. This post is me writing back.
Bio:
Conrad Youngblood is an author and publisher at Light Beings Press. He lives in Onalaska, Texas, and sees himself as a philosopher. His book Lost in the Sauce: Pain, Psychosis & Pleasure, a history of Psychopathia Sexualis and the long road from diagnosis to consent, is available on Amazon in Kindle, paperback, and hardcover: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0HQ5W7Y7L
